Recruiting problems often begin before the recruiter opens the first resume.
A hiring manager may say, “We need a strong Sales Manager with B2B experience.” At first, the task sounds clear. But after the first twenty resumes, questions start to appear. Does the candidate need experience with large enterprise clients? Is team management required? How important is industry experience? Can someone still be considered if their English level is not listed on the resume?
If these answers only appear during candidate review, the hiring criteria effectively start changing as the search progresses.
That is why it is useful to have a short kickoff conversation between the recruiter and the hiring manager before the search begins. This is often called a hiring manager intake meeting.
The purpose is not to read the job description together once again. After the meeting, the recruiter should clearly understand who the team is looking for, what genuinely matters, and how candidates should be evaluated.
1. Start with the reason for the hire, not the requirements
“What skills should this candidate have?” should not always be the first question.
First, clarify why the company needs this person at all.
For example:
Too vague: “We need a Sales Manager with at least five years of experience.”
More useful:
“Within the first six months, this person should be able to build relationships with large clients independently and manage their own portfolio.”
The second version makes it much easier to understand what kind of experience actually matters.
At the beginning, clarify:
- why the role is open;
- whether it is a new position or a replacement;
- what problem the new hire is expected to solve;
- what results are expected after three, six, or twelve months;
- who the person will work with and report to.
This helps the recruiter search for someone who can solve a specific business problem rather than simply match a list of skills.
2. Separate essential requirements from preferred ones
A common problem with job requirements is that almost everything gradually becomes “mandatory.”
Five years of experience. A specific industry. A particular tool. Team management experience. C1 English. Experience with large clients.
Eventually, the recruiter is no longer looking for someone who can do the job well, but for someone who can tick every box.
It is more useful to separate the criteria into three groups:
Essential. Without this, the candidate would struggle to perform the core responsibilities of the role.
Preferred. This is an advantage, but its absence should not automatically lead to rejection.
Can be learned. Something the person can realistically pick up after joining.
For example, experience selling a complex B2B product may be critical, while knowledge of one specific internal company system may not be.
This distinction helps avoid rejecting strong candidates simply because they do not match an ideal checklist 100%.
3. Decide what can actually be evaluated from a resume
Not every requirement can be assessed properly during the initial CV review.
A resume can often show industry experience, work with specific technologies, years of experience, project types, previous roles, and responsibilities.
But it is much harder to judge communication quality, motivation, the ability to work with difficult clients, or leadership style from a resume alone.
Before candidate review begins, it helps to agree on what should be evaluated from the resume and what should be left for a call or interview.
This prevents the team from trying to make a final judgment about a person based on a document that simply does not contain all the necessary information.
We cover the review process in more detail in our practical step-by-step guide to resume screening.
4. Agree on what “information not found” actually means
Imagine one of the requirements is:
Experience working with large enterprise clients.
The candidate has solid sales experience, but the size of their clients is not mentioned in the resume.
What does that mean?
Option 1: the candidate does not meet the requirement.
Option 2: there is not enough information, so it should be clarified later.
Those are very different decisions.
Missing information in a resume does not always mean missing experience. Sometimes it simply means the question should move to the next stage.
The recruiter and hiring manager should therefore agree in advance which gaps are real reasons for rejection and which only require clarification.
5. Define what a good shortlist should look like
“Send me a few strong candidates” sounds simple, but it does not say much.
It is better to agree in advance:
- how many candidates the hiring manager wants to see in the first batch;
- whether candidates who do not meet every requirement should still be included;
- whether strong alternative profiles are worth showing;
- what information should accompany each resume;
- which concerns or open questions the recruiter should highlight.
A good shortlist does not necessarily mean five “perfect” CVs. In some cases, it is more useful to present several strong but different profiles and explain why each one may fit the role.
6. Agree on the hiring stages before candidates enter the process
Another source of delay is designing the process while it is already happening.
A candidate completes an initial call, and only then does the team decide who should meet them next.
Before the search begins, define:
- what the hiring stages will be;
- who participates in each one;
- what is being evaluated at each interview;
- whether there will be an assignment;
- who makes the final decision;
- who provides feedback and within what timeframe.
The last point matters especially. If a recruiter finds a strong candidate in one day but the hiring manager responds a week later, fast sourcing does not create a fast hiring process.
7. Do not leave the agreement only in memory or chat messages
Even a good intake meeting is not very useful if, two weeks later, no one remembers exactly what was agreed.
The role criteria should remain accessible throughout the search.
Otherwise, a requirement may start as preferred, become mandatory after a few candidates, and then become optional again a week later.
That means different candidates are being evaluated by different rules.
It is better to keep the criteria connected to the vacancy and use them as a shared reference point throughout the hiring process.
How this can be organized in Qualex
In Qualex, the work starts with a separate workspace for the vacancy. You can define the role and candidate requirements, then upload resumes specifically in the context of those criteria.
This means the agreement about the ideal candidate does not remain separate in meeting notes. It becomes part of the actual resume review process.
During analysis, you can see which requirements are supported by the resume, where there may be gaps, and what deserves additional attention.
After the initial review, depending on the plan, you can continue working with candidates using saved cards, private notes, and statuses.
If you are just getting started with Qualex, see our step-by-step guide to your first resume review.
A short checklist before the search begins
Before opening the first resume, check whether you can clearly answer these questions:
- Why does the company need this person?
- What result is expected from them?
- Which requirements are truly essential?
- Which requirements are only preferred?
- What can be learned after hiring?
- What can be verified from a resume?
- What needs to be clarified later?
- Which missing information should not automatically mean rejection?
- What should a good shortlist look like?
- What are the hiring stages?
- Who provides feedback, and how quickly?
- Where will all these agreements be stored?
If most of these answers are clear, the recruiter starts the search with a concrete plan rather than a vague job description.
Summary
A good candidate search does not begin with the first resume.
It begins when the recruiter and hiring manager share the same understanding of why the role exists, who they are looking for, and how candidates will be evaluated.
The more of these questions are resolved before the search begins, the less often the team has to change the rules around individual candidates, reopen resumes, or clarify what the hiring manager meant in the first place.
An intake meeting does not have to be long. But it should leave the recruiter with three things: a clear understanding of the role, clear evaluation criteria, and an agreed hiring process.
Our socials
Follow Qualex updates, product news, and discount promo codes.